Game of Thrones shouldn't have followed the end of George R.R. Martin

0
14


In spite of the game of Thrones The conclusion came directly from the mind of George R.R. Martin, the ending was controversial and divisive; therefore, the show should have forged its own ending separate from the books. HBO's critically acclaimed fantasy series was adapted from Martin's long-running and, so far, unfinished series of books. A song of ice and fire. The show recently ended its eighth season last year, despite Martin claiming there was enough written and planned material in the books for more seasons.

Season 8 was a messy culmination of the show's downward spiral, which possibly started in season 5, got worse in season 7, and crashed and burned in season 8. Many of the qualities that made the show great were Completely absent from the final season, such as nuanced political intrigue and realistic depictions of war and combat, replaced by illogical plot points and ignorant character decisions. However, what closed the deal for many fans was the literal conclusion of the show: featuring Daenerys Targaryen (Emilia Clarke), the Mother of Dragons, and the Slave Liberator, turning her heel and becoming a mass murderer by burning King & # 39; s Landing to the ground.

Keep scrolling to continue reading
Click the button below to start this article in quick view.

Related: Game of Thrones: What Happened to the Red Priestess, Kinvara

With such a massive revelation, it's clear that the twist could only come from George R.R. Martin himself, which coincides with the author's reports that he had revealed the end of the books to showrunners David Benioff and D.B. Weiss years ago. Despite being an adaptation of Martin's work, game of Thrones It would have been better to create a different ending to her story than originally planned, because by season 8 the show had practically become a new narrative.

Certain parts of the GOT finale were always planned


As the showrunners revealed, certain elements of the end of the story had been revealed to them early, because Martin has not yet finished the books and the show outperformed the material written with season 6. These include details such as the revelation of parenthood. Jon Snow (Kit Harrington) (which Weiss and Benioff had to guess to secure rights to adapt the material), as well as the origins of the slow stable boy Hodor (Kristian Nairn). But in particular, Martin revealed the actual ending of the books to the show's writers, who fans can only assume made up the big features of season 8.

The biggest argument, of course, is the burning of Daenerys Targaryen from King's Landing. On the show, it's such a jarring transition for the character that the only way it could make sense is if it comes from the author himself. In the books, Martin has precious context and nuances that would serve to make Daenerys' fall from grace, while the show had to rush to the conclusion without the development necessary to properly write a character arc. The same can be said of Bran Stark (Isaac Hempstead Wright) who became King of Westeros; Aside from the actor himself revealing that Bran's fate came from Martin, it's another instance of a twist on the show that makes little or no sense outside of the context of planning the books.

Related: Crusader Kings 3 Preview: Game of Thrones-style strategy game

While the big events make sense to have come directly from George himself, there are also smaller intimate details that make sense as planned for the conclusion of the books. One that immediately comes to mind is Jon Snow, who killed Daenerys. Martin has repeatedly spoken about the irony that the series title is A song of ice and fire, from the contrast between dragons and white walkers, to the supernatural fight between the Great Other and the Lord of Light. But there is a deeper irony in the idea of ​​Jon Snow, a child from Winterfell, who falls in love with Daenerys Targaryen, the last of the Dragonriders, only to be inevitably forced to kill her. It speaks to the "bittersweet" nature that Martin has referred to several times in discussing the series finale. In addition to this, Jon Snow abandoning his titles and going with the savages to go beyond the Wall is also appropriate, as the books spend much more time spying on each other and their deep love for Ygritte than the show. .

Game of Thrones no longer fits Martin's story


By the time season 8 arrived, game of Thrones was a very different beast than A song of ice and fire. Admittedly, the stories still focused on the same characters, and the big plot events were still similar, but the show had always taken liberties with the source material. In the first four seasons, the changes were minor, but around Season 5, the writers began to realize that they would quickly get past the point in the story Martin had written. Because of this, major material changes began to occur to make up for gaps in the story that showrunners were unaware of. These include things like completely ignoring Lady Stoneheart as a character, radically changing Dorne's plot after Oberyn Martell's death, and the removal of Young Griff, a character Tyrion encounters on his way to Meereen, who may be the real one. son of Rhaegar Targaryen or a suitor of Blackfyre.

For the most part, every season of game of Thrones It was an adaptation of a singular book, with the exception of seasons 3 and 4. Looking at the book series this way, these dropped subplots may not have seemed important to the overall story in the eyes of Benioff and Weiss. However, looking back on what parts of the show's finale had been planned by Martin, it's obvious that the elements the show left out will be very important to the end of the books, even if fans still don't know how. This is just further proof that the supporting plots and characters left out during seasons 5, 6, and 7 pushed the show even further from Martin's original storyline, to the point of becoming his own narrative.

Changing the ending would have pleased fans


Although it is obvious that the show has gone downhill in terms of writing quality and thematic depth, what is responsible for the show's current cultural decline is the finale. Fans watched for 8 years eager to find out who would sit on the Iron Throne, and the ending they came up with just felt disappointing, despite being Martin's planned ending. The problem is that the show had lost much of the well-written nuances found in the books, and the first four seasons that Daenerys became a dictator who felt completely out of left field, despite that kind of change. character was extremely on the mark for the world of A song of ice and fire. For season 8, Game of thrones It had simply become entertainment for the public and fans alike, and the general audience did not want a bittersweet and morally complex ending.

Related: Game of Thrones: What Happened to the Mormont House After the Battle of Winterfell

If the show had written a different ending, one that would please fans at the cost of abandoning the originally planned conclusion by George R.R. Martin, it would not have such a ruined perception in the eyes of pop culture. Despite its flaws in the final seasons, game of Thrones It still had a massive fan base and lasts until the end. What disappointed fans of the show the most was not its slow decline in writing and characterization (although everyone knew it happened), the final blow was the disappointing ending. Hypothetically, if the show had gone with one of the fan theories for its finale, one that audiences latched onto like Daenerys or Jon sitting on the Throne, it would have been indulging the fan service, but would have given Most of those same fans a satisfying conclusion. The problem is, the show wanted to have their cake and eat it too – by ditching most of the back half of the source material and at the same time drawing the high-level conclusion. As a result, the public everywhere rejected the disparity.

The show could have kept the surprise from Martin's ending


George R.R. Martin Game of Thrones

The most unfortunate aspect of the final season of game of Thrones It is not that the ending is poorly executed, but that it spoils the twist of Martin's books. This was something that was felt with the revelation of Jon Snow's paternity in season 6, as there were dedicated fans of the books who had been waiting for nearly 30 years to uncover that secret only to be told in an adaptation. Part of the blame falls on Martin himself for not finishing the series by now, but it is tragic that his work has been overcome and finished through a lower quality version.

If the show had ended with an original ending, it would not only have pleased fans, but would have also preserved the integrity of Martin's ending. Although it is unanimously assumed that Martin's version of the finale will be better written and more context-appropriate, the element of surprise will never be recovered. Benioff and Weiss could have written a satisfying conclusion to the show's narrative, setting fans up to read Martin's book hoping for one thing, only the alternative completely defeats them. Unfortunately, instead of being a satisfying but alternative narrative in its own right, game of Thrones He will always be remembered for losing the ball in his final season and becoming a pop culture outcast in the process.

More: Game of Thrones ended 1 year ago today: what the reaction was wrong

Smallville: when each main character discovered that Clark was Superman



LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here